moral luck

moral luck
(MOHR.ul luk)
n.
The principle that the perceived morality of a person's actions sometimes depends on luck or chance.
Example Citation:
Kant sought to make morality as pure and disconnected as possible from the vagaries of circumstance and individual personality. Whether an action is right or wrong was to depend solely on the principle of action that lay behind it, and in particular on whether the agent could regard that principle as one that everyone ought to follow in all possible circumstances. Professor Williams ingeniously showed how hard it is for any such insular conception of morality to survive contact with the messiness of real life. He coined the term "moral luck" to mark a fact that is incomprehensible to Kantians, but which — once he had highlighted it — came to seem undeniable: that whether or not a person's behaviour emerges as good or bad can sometimes depend on pure chance. Soldiers know that a man can become a hero partly by accident. The ancient tragedians knew that he could be undone by fate, which comes to much the same thing.
— "Bernard Williams," The Economist, June 28, 2003
Earliest Citation:
I was bicycling down the main street in Oxford and getting ready to turn right. (This was England, where a right turn is a left turn.) In a hurry, I gave only a quick look back before pulling away from the curb. I didn't see the cyclist behind me, crashed into him, and sent him sprawling into the roadway.
The cyclist was lucky. If there had been a car coming he would have been killed, but there wasn't. He brushed off his clothes, accepted my apology, and continued down the street.
I too was lucky. If there had been a car coming I would have been guilty of carelessly killing someone, a serious moral wrong. As it was, I had been only harmlessly negligent - nothing to be proud of, but no great sin.
But wait. How can luck have the second effect? How can fortune affect the wrongness of what I did? ...
Consider a feature of our legal system: it punishes attempted crimes less severely than successful ones.
This might make sense if the law's purpose were just to prevent crimes. Stiffer penalties for successful crimes dissuade people who've already tried a crime unsuccessfully from trying it again. But if punishment is a response to guilt, the law is puzzling: why should a gunman be thought less guilty if his victim wore a bullet-proof vest?
We believe, it seems in "moral luck," in luck that affects not only what happens but the moral quality of what we do.
— Thomas Hurka, "Questions of principle," The Globe and Mail, April 10, 1990
First Use:
— Bernard Williams, "Moral Luck," The Aristotelian Society Supplementary Volume 1, 1976
Notes:
The "Professor Williams" mentioned in the above citation is the English moral philosopher Bernard Williams, who died last month.
Related Words: Categories:

New words. 2013.

Игры ⚽ Поможем решить контрольную работу

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Moral luck — describes circumstances whereby a moral agent is assigned moral blame or praise for an action or its consequences even though it is clear that said agent did not have full control over either the action or its consequences. This term, introduced… …   Wikipedia

  • moral luck — A phenomenon investigated particularly by Williams and Thomas Nagel . In the Kantian tradition, a person s moral worth depends only on the quality of their will, and is thus independent of external circumstance. But reflection shows that our… …   Philosophy dictionary

  • Moral character — or character is an evaluation of a particular individual s durable moral qualities. The concept of character can imply a variety of attributes including the existence or lack of virtues such as integrity, courage, fortitude, honesty, and loyalty …   Wikipedia

  • Moral psychology — is a field of study in both philosophy and psychology. Some use the term moral psychology relatively narrowly to refer to the study of moral development.[1] However, others tend to use the term more broadly to include any topics at the… …   Wikipedia

  • Moral responsibility — For other types of responsibility, see Responsibility (disambiguation). Part of a series on Freedom …   Wikipedia

  • Luck egalitarianism — is a view about distributive justice espoused by a variety of egalitarian and left wing political philosophers. According to this view, justice demands that variations in how well off people are should be wholly attributable to the responsible… …   Wikipedia

  • Moral Mazes — (ISBN 0 19 506080 6), named the Most Outstanding Business and Management Book of 1988 by the Association of American Publishers[citation needed] …   Wikipedia

  • Luck — For other uses, see Luck (disambiguation). Good luck redirects here. For other uses, see Good Luck (disambiguation). A four leaf clover is often considered to bestow good luck. Luck or fortuity is good fortune which occurs beyond one s control,… …   Wikipedia

  • Problema de la suerte moral — Saltar a navegación, búsqueda El problema de la suerte moral es el problema ético que surge porque en muchos casos, parece correcto evaluar moralmente a un agente pese a que una parte importante de aquello por lo cual es evaluado depende de… …   Wikipedia Español

  • Socrates and the beginnings of moral philosophy — Hugh H.Benson INTRODUCTION Cicero in Tusculan Disputations famously tells us that Socrates first called philosophy down from the sky, set it in cities and even introduced it into homes, and compelled it to consider life and morals, good and evil …   History of philosophy

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”